As promised, I conducted a second round of comparisons for these top three job search engines at exactly 10:30 PM central time last night. The results are as follows:
Overall rankings:
#1: Indeed. Indeed and SimplyHired are virtually tied in terms of search results relevancy. SimplyHired returned one CEO opening at the top of the results (the only one listed in the top ten results). Once again, Indeed lists two assistants to the CEO as top results, but it did return two CEO openings right after those (the only ones among the top ten results). So if we just compare the search results it’s a tie, but given the reasons that I mentioned last time (SimplyHired put sponsor links over such results that were not even relevant in this case), I give Indeed #1.
#2: SimplyHired. (For reasons mentioned above)
#3: Oodle. Oodle continues to underperform compared to the other two competitors. There were no CEO positions in the top three listings at all. The first one didn’t occur until the seventh listing (even worse than last time).
Here are the screenshots:
